Robert Rauschenberg incorporated a silkscreen of Martin Beebe’s photograph Diver into his 1974 mixed-media work Pull, without the permission of Beebe. Although Rauschenberg believed he had sufficiently transformed the work, Beebe was upset when he saw Pull reproduced in a 1976 Time magazine article and requested compensation from Rauschenberg. When initial attempts to negotiate failed, Beebe sued Rauschenberg for copyright infringement. This case settled out of court before a verdict was reached. Rauschenberg did not admit wrongdoing, but paid Beebe $3,000 and agreed to credit Beebe in future catalogs featuring Pull.